The Great Comic Book Detectives #5

Here's the bit. You, the readers, send in descriptions of comics that you remember vague details from the past and either I, or one of the readers of the piece will use detective work to figure out what comic you're talking about!
Here's the latest one, from reader Jay...
An anthology horror/suspense/mystery comic book from sometime between [...] http://tinyurl.com/yc44pgx